These Cups Runneth Over 
Our scrumptious, homemade peanut butter cups combine smooth milk chocolate with creamy, natural peanut butter filling at their center. A true indulgence. 

$3.50 each, $5 for two

Packaging Preferences?
We package your order for shipping efficiency. If you’re ordering multiple products and would like them packed individually or grouped a certain way, please add a note in the “ORDER NOTE” shopping cart section, and we’ll do our best to accommodate your request.

The Original Sin.  
Provincetown Fudge Factory’s premiere flavor! Our decadent, rich and creamy homemade chocolate fudge is made fresh daily.

$11.48 PER 1/2 LB
GET 1/2 LB FREE FOR EVERY 2 LBS PURCHASED  (OF THE SAME FLAVOR)

Packaging Preferences?
We package your order for shipping efficiency. If you’re ordering multiple products and would like them packed individually or grouped a certain way, please add a note in the “ORDER NOTE” shopping cart section, and we’ll do our best to accommodate your request.

A New England Native  
Our penuche (or Panucci in Italian) homemade fudge is made with brown sugar, milk, butter, and a hint of vanilla. Brown sugar (instead of white sugar) delivers butterscotch and maple tones to this local favorite. 

$11.48 PER 1/2 LB
GET 1/2 LB FREE FOR EVERY 2 LBS PURCHASED  (OF THE SAME FLAVOR)

Packaging Preferences?
We package your order for shipping efficiency. If you’re ordering multiple products and would like them packed individually or grouped a certain way, please add a note in the “ORDER NOTE” shopping cart section, and we’ll do our best to accommodate your request.

These Cups Runneth Over 
Our scrumptious, homemade peanut butter cups combine rich dark chocolate with creamy, natural peanut butter filling at their center. A true indulgence. 

$3.50 each, $5 for two

Packaging Preferences?
We package your order for shipping efficiency. If you’re ordering multiple products and would like them packed individually or grouped a certain way, please add a note in the “ORDER NOTE” shopping cart section, and we’ll do our best to accommodate your request.

These Cups Runneth Over 
Our scrumptious, homemade peanut butter cups combine rich dark chocolate with crunchy, natural peanut butter filling at their center. A true indulgence. 

$3.50 each, $5 for two

Packaging Preferences?
We package your order for shipping efficiency. If you’re ordering multiple products and would like them packed individually or grouped a certain way, please add a note in the “ORDER NOTE” shopping cart section, and we’ll do our best to accommodate your request.