Skip to content

WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING! WE NOW OFFER UPS SHIPPING!

SPEND $50+ AND FREE SHIPPING IS ON US THRU 12/18/25!

Stocking Stuffers
Fudge
Peanut Butter Cups
Grab & Go
Truffles
Turtles
Chocolate
Candy
- Gummies
- Jelly Treats
- Licorice
- Malted Balls
- Sours
- Swedish Fish
Nuts
- Almonds
- Cashews
- Peanuts
- Pecans
- Walnuts
Taffy
Sugar-Free

Instagram
Facebook

Cart

Order note

Gift message

No gift message

Include blank card (I'll write my own message)

Handwrite my message

Subtotal

$0.00

Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

Read Terms of Agreement Close

Adding Shipping Protection to an order 100% guarantees the order from damage, loss, or theft, and enables Provincetown Fudge Factory to replace or refund your order immediately.

Without Shipping Protection, Provincetown Fudge Factory cannot guarantee replacement or refund for lost, damaged, return-to-sender, or stolen shipments until USPS reviews and resolves the issue, which may take time.

Provincetown Fudge Factory doesn’t provide delivery estimates or guarantee USPS estimated delivery dates. Orders are fulfilled Mon thru Wed, to facilitate Mon thru Sat deliveries. Late deliveries aren’t refunded or replaced.

Agreement of our Terms of Agreement is required to checkout.

Your cart is currently empty.

Stocking Stuffers
Fudge
Peanut Butter Cups
Grab & Go
Truffles
Turtles
Chocolate
Candy
Nuts
Taffy
Sugar-Free

Search

Home / Collections / Coconut Haystacks

Filter

Chocolate Treats (7)
Grab & Go (4)

Coconut (7)
Dark Chocolate (3)
Milk Chocolate (3)
White Chocolate (3)

Chocolate (2)
Coconut (7)
Dark Chocolate (1)
Milk Chocolate (2)
White Chocolate (2)

Coconut Haystacks

Sort

Bark
Buttercrunch
Coconut Haystacks
Cookies
Malted Balls
Nonpareils
Pretzels
Sea Salt Caramels
S’mores
Sugar-Free

White Chocolate Coconut Haystacks

Milk Chocolate Coconut Haystacks

Dark Chocolate Coconut Haystacks

Petite Dark Chocolate Coconut Haystacks: Grab & Go

Petite Milk Chocolate Coconut Haystacks: Grab & Go

Petite White Chocolate Coconut Haystacks: Grab & Go

Petite Coconut Haystack Mix: Grab & Go

Digital Gift Cards with Video

CELEBRATING 40+ YEARS IN PROVINCETOWN!

Provincetown Fudge Factory has been making world-famous, original recipe fudge since 1984.

210 Commercial Street
Provincetown, MA 02657

We reserve the right to refuse service to anyone.

Fudge
Peanut Butter Cups
Truffles
Turtles
Barks
Chocolate
Grab & Go
Gummies
Candy & Taffy
Sugar-Free
Tees

About Us
Location + Hours
Contact Us
Deals
General FAQs
Shipping FAQs
Refund Policy
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
Digital Gift Cards w/ Video!
Check Gift Card Balance

Instagram
Facebook

SWEETEN THE DEAL

Be first to hear about our money-saving promotions when you opt-in to receive our Sweet-e-Blasts.

Enter your email Subscribe

© 2025 Provincetown Fudge Factory

Coconut Haystacks